Sudbury Soils Study
Public
Advisory Committee – Meeting #25
January 17,
2006 – 7:00 p.m.
Gold Room,
Science North
Attendees: Ersin
Abdullah Nicole Breau Dick Cowan
John
Hogenbirk Gary Hrytsak Aino Laamanen
Bob Somek
Regrets: Darrell
Alston Carol Zippel Rubina
Nebenionquit
Independent
Process Observer: Franco
Mariotti
TC
Members: Marc Butler Brian McMahon Stephen Monet
Glen Watson
SARA
Group: Trevor
Smith-Higgins
Chair: John
Hogenbirk
Recorder: Julie
Sabourin
Public (6) Media
______________________________________________________________________
JOHN
HOGENBIRK PRESIDING
1.0 CALL TO ORDER
The meeting was called to order at 7:00 p.m. following
dinner.
2.0 INTRODUCTIONS
Members of the PAC, TC and SARA introduced themselves to the
public in attendance.
3.0 DECLARATION
OF CONFLICT OF INTEREST
FRANCO
MARIOTTI PRESIDING
4.0 ELECTION OF
OFFICERS
At this stage of the meeting the
Independent Process Observer assumed the role of Chair to conduct the election
of officers for 2006 as follows:
4.1 Election of Chair
1-2006 Moved by Cowan - Laamanen: That John Hogenbirk be
appointed as Chair of the PAC for the year 2006. CARRIED
4.2 Election of Vice-Chair
2-2006 Moved by Cowan - Abdullah: That Gary Hrytsak be appointed as Vice- Chair of the PAC for the
year 2006. CARRIED
JOHN
HOGENBIRK PRESIDING
4.3 Membership Renewals
The
following PAC members’ appointments expire in March and they have requested
reappointment:
Bob
Somek Carol Zippel Ersin Abdullah
PAC
concurred with their reappointment.
5.0 OPEN FORUM
(30 min.)
There were no questions raised from the audience.
6.0 ADDITIONS
TO/APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA
It was requested 11.1 – Membership Renewals be moved to
follow the Election of Officers.
7.0 REPORT ON
QUESTIONS/ISSUES RAISED AT LAST PAC MEETING
There were no items that needed to
be addressed.
8.0 PRESENTATION
8.1 SSS Communication Plan
Trevor
Smith-Higgins was asked to consult with the CSC of the TC regarding the
Communication Plan regarding strategies that needed to take place. Highlights of his presentation included a
list of the objectives of the Plan which identified the stakeholders,
communication strategies, the spokesperson protocol, key messages, stand-by
statements, initiatives, venues, schedule and next steps. He also noted that there will be a Plain
Language Summary Report to be released concurrently with the final SSS
Report.
It was asked when the details regarding the public open
session with the TERA Group will be released.
Trevor replied that the schedule will be populated once the information
becomes available. There was concern expressed regarding the timeline for the
public to review the final report due to the size of the document. It was noted the TC will take this under
advisement.
9.0 APPROVAL OF
MINUTES
9.1 Minutes of Meeting #24 – November 15, 2005
It was noted that Brian McMahon was absent from this meeting.
Item 10.1: It was
requested that the first sentence be amended to read “…completion dates as
seasons so as not to provide the public with inaccurate timelines as dates are
often altered due to extenuating circumstances.”
Item 11.1: It was
requested to include (cancelled) following the notation of the January 12, 2006
meeting as it was cancelled.
10.0 BUSINESS
ARISING FROM MINUTES
10.1 PAC Policy on Public Presentations
At the previous PAC
meeting it was agreed that this policy needed to be amended to clarify the
timelines for response to the public on issues raised at a PAC meeting.
4-2006 Moved
by Somek – Hrytsak: That the revisions to the PAC Policy on Public
Presentations be adopted. CARRIED
This
document is to be forwarded to the TC for their information.
11.0 NEW BUSINESS
11.1 Membership Renewals
Please refer to item
4.3.
11.2 Review of PAC Terms of Reference
This document requires annual review.
5-2006 Moved
by Cowan – Somek: That the PAC Terms of
Reference by approved without amendment. CARRIED
Further
to this review and the issue of the longevity of the PAC as noted in the Terms
of Reference, the PAC requested that this item be brought to the TC for further
discussion. It was noted by members of
the WG that this item, as well as the duration of the TC, next steps, etc., was
requested by the TC for the WG to frame the issue for discussion at their next
meeting.
11.3 PAC
Annual Report
This
document, prepared by Carol Zippel and John Hogenbirk was completed with input
from the rest of the committee.
6-2006 Moved
by Laamanen – Hrytsak: That the PAC
approves the contents of the 2006 Annual Report. CARRIED
This
report is now to be forwarded to the TC for their information and then placed
on the SSS website for public review.
12.0 TC MEETINGS
This
document was tabled for information. It
appeared that not all members of the PAC had a copy and a request was made for
it to be re-distributed.
13.0 ADDENDUM
13.1 Progress
of SSS Report
The WG noted that Volume 1 has been
commented upon, Volume 2 comments have been submitted by most members and there
has been partial distribution of Volume 3 with the rest to be distributed in
February. These reviews are now the
focus of the TC hence the occasional cancellation of meetings to allow members
to continue with the review process.
It was also noted that once comments
have been incorporated the volumes will be sent to the TERA group where they
will make the necessary copies and distribute to their reviewers as
appropriate.
13.2 IPO Report
It was requested that these reports
be placed on the PAC agenda for information and discussion. The IPO indicated his next report will
likely be out by the 15th of February.
14.0 NEXT PAC MEETING
March 21, 2006 Gold Room Science North
15.0 FOLLOW UP TO
PUBLIC SSESSION
There
were no items noted.
16.0 ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 8:50 p.m.
_________________________ ________________________
Chair, John
Hogenbirk Recorder,
Julie Sabourin